Directors’ loan accounts and the bed and breakfast traps (2024)

Shared from Tax Insider: Directors’ loan accounts and the bed and breakfast traps

Lee Sharpe looks at the anti-avoidance rules for loans to participators and how HMRC likely regrets taking a case before the general anti-avoidance rule panel.

This article looks at loans to participators, the anti-avoidance rules introduced to try to prevent manipulation of the regime, and a general anti-abuse rule (GAAR) panel opinion published in July 2022 that the taxpayer ‘won’ – the first time this has happened!

Basics of directors’ loan accounts
Readers should be familiar with the basic aspects of directors loan accounts (DLAs) being:

It can mean either a formal loan account or something more informal between the company and the director, where the company will often settle the director’s private liabilities.

We usually assume that the director is also a shareholder in the company (and, as such, a ‘participator’ in the company).

The company is ‘close’, meaning that it is controlled by five or fewer participators (see above) or by any number of director-shareholders.

Tax implications: Benefit-in-kind
A DLA is usually interest-free. Where interest is nil or lower than HMRC broadly deems a commercial rate, there is a taxable benefit-in-kind under ITEPA 2003, Pt 3, Ch 7 (s 173 onwards). The charge is because the director is treated as an employee.

The current official rate of deemed interest taxable benefit is ‘only’ 2% per annum, which is quite modest (but may soon rise if inflation drives up high street lending rates).

The benefit is triggered only if the DLA balance exceeds £10,000 at any point in the tax year; however, once it does exceed the threshold, the loan is chargeable for the whole period for which it was taken out during the tax year, not just the period in which it exceeded the de minimis threshold.

Even though the taxable benefit is considered quite modest, it is an annual tax charge, so it may eventually prove expensive if the loan is substantial and triggers the charge for several years.

Tax implications: Loans to participators
A DLA will trigger a temporary charge to corporation tax on the company if it remains outstanding for too long. This is a charge on the company and is triggered where the loan is made to a participator (broadly, shareholder), and the company is ‘close’. Regardless of the control criteria outlined above, a company that is not resident in the UK is not close.

The ‘section 455’ tax charge will arise if the loan has not been repaid or formally released within nine months (plus a day, strictly) of the end of the company’s chargeable period in which the loan was advanced (or, if previously advanced, a later period in which it was increased). This coincides with the standard date for the company’s settling its corporation tax liability, assuming it is not paying by instalments.

The section 455 charge is reduced to the extent that the original loan has been repaid or formally released within the required ‘nine months’ timeframe. The charge is now 33.75% (for advances from 1 April 2022) and the adjustment to dividend taxation that correlates to the health and social care levy.

Once a section 455 tax charge is payable, HMRC gets to keep the money for at least a year, as any tax repayment (following further part or full repayment, formal release, etc. of the loan itself) is due nine months and a day after the company’s chargeable period in which the loan is (part) repaid, written off, etc., subject to the company making a claim.

If the company does not claim the relief within four years of the end of the company’s chargeable period in which the repayment, release, etc. occurs, the tax may be forfeit (CTA 2010, s 458(3)).

Further anti-avoidance measures
The section 455 charge effectively forces the company to pay a deposit equivalent to the hypothetical income tax a ‘high-earning’ individual shareholder would normally pay, so that the Treasury does not lose out if the company never asks for the money back. The benefit-in-kind tax charge, in turn, addresses any low-interest advantage.

Even though the section 455 charge rules were widely drawn, the legislation did not explicitly address where a director-shareholder repays the loan just before the initial nine-month deadline, avoids the company charge, and then takes out further loans soon afterwards – postponing a section 455 tax charge by a further 12 months (commonly called ‘bed and breakfasting’ the loans). In 2013, HMRC consulted on reforming the regime – which included a proposal to make the temporary tax charge permanent!

While HMRC eventually saw sense, it meanwhile introduced special anti-avoidance provisions to combat such loan ‘bed and breakfasting’ (in FA 2013) in particular, what is now CTA 2010, s 464C.

30-day rule
Where the participator repays at least £5,000 against some or all of the initial loan but then borrows further funds from the company within 30 days of that repayment, the benefit of the repayment is restricted by the later borrowing.

A bit like the CGT share identification rules, the repayment is matched with the following advance rather than the original loan, so more of the original loan remains exposed to the imminent section 455 tax charge.

Arrangements rule
Where the 30-day rule is not in point, and the loan outstanding is at least £15,000 and the individual makes a repayment but at that point there is an intention or arrangement in place to ‘re-borrow’ at least £5,000 – at broadly any future date.

This is much more open-ended and is likely to be pursued where HMRC sees several cycles of repayment-then-further-withdrawals-beyond-30-days.

Taxed income antidote
The anti-avoidance legislation excludes where the repayment by the individual has been subject to income tax – typically, salary or dividend paid to the director-shareholder.

However, HMRC insists that the salary, dividend, etc. must be from the same company that made the loan (see HMRC’s Company Taxation manual at CTM61642).

General anti-abuse rule
HMRC recently took a ‘loans to participators’ case to the GAAR advisory panel, and the panel’s opinion was published on 21 July 2022. The scenario was relatively simple; the director-shareholder took the initial loan from the parent company of a group and then repaid the loan by borrowing on commercial terms from a subsidiary (‘bed-and-sub’, if you will). HMRC considered this to be abusive.

The GAAR panel agreed that the arrangements were to avoid tax but said they did not involve contrived or abnormal steps; the provisions could still bite, albeit at a later date, and no value had permanently escaped a tax charge.

This is the first GAAR hearing HMRC has ‘lost’, and it is no doubt furious.

Conclusion
The benefit-in-kind rules for taxable cheap loans and the section 455 tax charge regime can be complex in the fine detail. The taxable cheap loan charges become notably less cheap as interest rates start to rise. We may also see much closer scrutiny of DLAs when making tax digital for companies eventually rolls out.

The section 455 tax charge can be triggered if loans are taken out intentionally, or even ‘accidentally’, such as when a shareholder receives a dividend that is deemed ultra vires or ‘illegal’ and must be repaid; certainly, HMRC will argue that a tax charge arises until such dividends are repaid by any director-shareholder who, in HMRC’s eyes, should have known better. See the Company Taxation manual at CTM20090 and CTM15205. But, as I have had in the past to explain to an HMRC officer, section 455 tax is chargeable only on loans to individuals, not loans to other companies.

Once HMRC has recovered from the trauma of ‘losing’ at the GAAR panel, it seems very likely we shall see urgent revisions to the loans to participators regime to ‘clarify’ that the legislation actually worked as HMRC said it did, all along – notably, across groups of companies.

Lee Sharpe looks at the anti-avoidance rules for loans to participators and how HMRC likely regrets taking a case before the general anti-avoidance rule panel.

This article looks at loans to participators, the anti-avoidance rules introduced to try to prevent manipulation of the regime, and a general anti-abuse rule (GAAR) panel opinion published in July 2022 that the taxpayer ‘won’ – the first time this has happened!

Basics of directors’ loan accounts
Readers should be familiar with the basic aspects of directors loan accounts (DLAs) being:

It can mean either a formal loan account or something more informal between the company and the director, where the company will often settle the director’s private liabilities.

We usually assume that the director is also a shareholder in the company (and, as such, a ‘participator’ in the company).

... Shared from Tax Insider: Directors’ loan accounts and the bed and breakfast traps

Directors’ loan accounts and the bed and breakfast traps (2024)

FAQs

Directors’ loan accounts and the bed and breakfast traps? ›

The main tax traps include:

What is included in directors loan account? ›

What is a Director's Loan Account? A director's loan is defined as funds a director deposits into and takes from the business that fall outside of expense reimbursements, salary or dividends. Directors' loans can go either way, with the director lending the company money or taking money out.

What is the 30 day rule for overdrawn directors loan account? ›

If you repay one loan to your company, you must wait at least 30 days before you're able to take out another one. If HMRC decide that the way you repay and withdraw money to and from your director's loan account looks like tax avoidance – beware!

How to reduce a director's loan account? ›

SUMMARY OF HOW TO CLEAR DIRECTOR LOAN ACCOUNT

Pay extra salary as a bonus to the Directors. Ensure all expenses have been claimed. Formally write off the Director's Loan Account. Use a combination of the dividends, salary, expense claims and writing off to clear the loan account.

What is Section 455 bed and breakfasting? ›

Bed and Breakfasting rules applies to the directors who borrow from their personal companies. If a director is using company's money, tax might be charged. The tax (known as Section 455 charge) is charged if the year-end loan balance is not paid back until 9 months.

How much interest can I charge on a director's loan? ›

The interest (which can be at a commercial rate that 3rd party lenders would otherwise offer) can be accrued and paid out when cash flow permits. Such interest rates could be up to ~8%.

Can dividends be paid to a director's loan account? ›

When a dividend is declared but not taken, it is credited to your directors loan account thereby reducing an overdrawn directors loan account balance or creating a balance owed to you.

Can I take money out of my directors loan account? ›

As well as paying money into your Limited Company, it is likely that you will also take money out of your director's loan account during the year. This is generally going to consist of: Personal expenses, such as fuel, your car insurance and services along with food and drink.

How do I offset my directors loan account? ›

Offset any loans the directors have made to the company (this is called set off). Take your full salary but reduce the cash you take out of the business to gradually offset the account. So pay yourself $5,000 per month but take $1,000 only with the balance being set against the loan account.

What happens if I don't pay back my director's loan? ›

If you have an overdrawn director's loan account and you are unable to repay it nine months and one day after your company's year end, HMRC will charge the company interest on the loan and this will accumulate until the S455 corporation tax or the director's loan is repaid.

How is Section 455 calculated? ›

455 tax is calculated at 33.75% of the loan outstanding at the year-end (for loans or advances made prior to 6 April 2022 the s. 455 tax charged was 32.5% of the loan). Effectively, the charge amounts to the higher rate of income tax charged on dividends.

What is a Section 455 tax charge? ›

When Does Section 455 Charge Apply? If a participator (i.e., director) receives loan from his company and does not pay within 9 months and 1 day after the end of accounting period, tax (known as s455 charge) is charged at the rate of 33.75% of the outstanding loan balance (32.5% before 6 April 2022).

What is the subsection 55 2 of the Income Tax Act? ›

Subsection 55(2) is an anti-avoidance rule intended to prevent the conversion of a taxable capital gain into a tax-free inter-corporate dividend.

Is directors loan account the same as drawings? ›

Legally, there's no separation between the business and it's sole proprietor. So, instead of having a director's loan account, you would have a Proprietor's Drawings Account. The same theory applies, you could tag any payments made by the sole trader from this 'bank account' instead of the current account.

How to show director's loan in balance sheet? ›

At the end of the financial year, the directors loan account balance is recorded in the balance sheet as either an asset (money owed to the Company by the director) if the loan account is overdrawn, or a liability (money owed to the director by the company) if the account is in credit.

What is the directors loan account in the chart of accounts? ›

Create new nominal codes
Nominal CodeNameSection of Chart of Accounts
1200Bank AccountCurrent Assets / Liabilities
2301Director's LoanLong Term Liabilities If the loan is to be repaid within one year, it should be set up as a Current Liability.
7903Loan Interest PaidOverheads
Dec 21, 2023

Is a directors loan account a creditor or debtor? ›

DLA is an account on the company financial records that reports all transactions between the director and the company. Amounts due to the director from the company should be recorded in the company's books as a creditor while the amounts due from the director to the company should be recorded as a debtor.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Greg Kuvalis

Last Updated:

Views: 6466

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (75 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Greg Kuvalis

Birthday: 1996-12-20

Address: 53157 Trantow Inlet, Townemouth, FL 92564-0267

Phone: +68218650356656

Job: IT Representative

Hobby: Knitting, Amateur radio, Skiing, Running, Mountain biking, Slacklining, Electronics

Introduction: My name is Greg Kuvalis, I am a witty, spotless, beautiful, charming, delightful, thankful, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.